As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. When you click a product link on muslimrestaurant.com and buy something on Amazon, Amazon pays us a small commission; the price you pay is the same.
Shopping for a kunafa tray should be simple, but most copper trays are made for serving, not baking. Here is how nine options stack up for beginners watching every dollar.
60-second summary: the best copper kunafa tray depends on whether you want to bake or only serve. For baking, the DLK aluminum set is the only one built for stovetop kunafa. For serving on a budget, MyGift and Godinger lead. Alisveristime adds Turkish style, Bonito suits hosts, Sertodo is the premium heirloom route, and the two Achla trays rank last.
Here is the catch most listings skip. Only one of these nine is sold as a kunafa pan. The rest are decorative or serving trays, and several are copper-plated rather than solid copper. That is fine if you know it going in.
We weighed material, size, stove suitability, price tier and owner feedback. Beginners get the most value from a simple, forgiving tray, so ease of use counts heavily. This guide comes from muslimrestaurant.com.
Key Takeaways
- Few Trays Are Real Kunafa Pans: Only the DLK set is sold for baking kunafa; the other eight are serving or decorative trays.
- Copper-Look Is Not Solid Copper: Most picks are plated or coated aluminum or stainless steel, and only the two Sertodo platters are pure copper.
- Budget Trays Do the Job: Under-$50 class trays earn the best owner feedback, so a premium price rarely makes a beginner's kunafa better.
- Check Food Use Before Buying: Some owners of the Achla round tray warn against using it for food, so read each listing's intended use.
- Size Matters More Than Shine: Owners of some trays say they run smaller than expected, so check the inner diameter against your recipe.
Our Top Picks for Copper Kunafa Tray
- DLK Kunefe Tray Set (2-pack): the only purpose-built, gas-stove-safe kunafa pan here, at a budget-friendly tier.
- MyGift Hammered Copper Tray: well-reviewed, affordable and attractive for serving finished kunafa.
- Godinger Burnt Copper Platter: the most reviewed pick with strong ratings, ideal for display on a budget.
The Best Copper Kunafa Tray: Reviewed
1. DLK Kunefe Tray Set: The Only True Kunafa Pan
Verdict: A two-piece aluminum set designed for baking kunafa on a gas or electric stove. It is silver, not copper, but it is the most practical choice here for beginners.
If your goal is making kunafa rather than just displaying it, this is the one that fits. The listing says it is designed for baking kunefe on an electric or gas stove, and it carries a gas-stove-safe feature. Nothing else in this group makes that claim.
You get two 13.75-inch trays with an inner diameter of 11.75 inches, a height of 0.8 inch and a weight of about a pound each. That thin, light build heats quickly, which suits stovetop cooking. Two trays also let you make a second batch or serve guests without waiting.
It is aluminum in a silver finish, so you will not get the copper look. For many cooks that is a fair trade. It is made in Turkey, hand-wash only, and the listing advises against wire brushes and bleach.
It sits in the under-$50 class for the pair, which works out to a modest cost per tray. The 4.2-star average comes from only 40 ratings, so evidence is thinner than for the bigger sellers. Still, for a first kunafa tray, this is the lowest-risk choice.
What Owners Say
Written owner comments are limited, so the main signal is the 4.2-star average across 40 ratings. That is solid rather than glowing. The listing itself stresses easy cleaning and long reuse, but hand-washing is required.
What we like
- Sold specifically for kunafa baking
- Gas stove safe and works on electric
- Two trays in one set
- Light and quick to heat
- Made in Turkey
What could be better
- Silver aluminum, not copper in look
- Hand wash only; no dishwasher
- Fewer ratings than the big sellers
- Thin 1.10 mm build can dent if handled roughly
Best for: Beginners who want to actually bake kunafa on the stove Not for: Anyone who wants a copper finish
| Material | Aluminum |
|---|---|
| Color | Silver |
| Special Feature | Gas Stove Safe |
| Style | Modern |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Desserts |
| Number of Pieces | 2 |
| Included Components | Cake Dish |
| Item Type Name | plate |
| Reusability | High |
| Manufacture Year | 2023 |
2. MyGift 11 Inch Hammered Copper Tray: Best Budget Serving
Verdict: A hammered aluminum tray with a copper-plated finish, a strong 4.6 rating and a friendly price. Great for serving kunafa slices, not for baking.
MyGift gives you the copper look without the premium cost. It is an 11-inch round aluminum tray with a hammered pattern and copper-plated finish, handcrafted in India. At roughly one inch tall with a raised edge, it holds slices of kunafa, dates or sweets without sliding.
It carries a 4.6 rating from 228 reviews, which is a healthy sample for a budget tray. The listing suggests uses from serving appetizers and desserts to holding toiletries, so it is flexible once your dessert is plated.
The limits matter. The listing states a maximum weight recommendation of 1.1 pounds, so it is not for heavy platters. It is also not marketed for stove or oven use, so do not treat it as a baking pan. Aluminum plated in copper will not behave like solid copper either.
For a budget-minded beginner, this is a safe, low-effort way to present finished kunafa. Pair it with a simple baking pan and you have a complete setup for less than a single premium platter.
What Owners Say
Owners repeatedly call it beautiful, and one mentions it as a fall countertop display. Quality feedback is positive overall. The main disagreement is size, as some find it a good fit while others say it is smaller than expected.
What we like
- Attractive hammered copper look
- Strong 4.6 rating across 228 reviews
- Raised edge keeps items in place
- Budget-friendly price tier
- Works for food, drinks and decor
What could be better
- Some owners say it is smaller than expected
- Low 1.1 lb weight recommendation
- Not made for baking or stove use
- Copper-plated, not solid copper
Best for: Budget shoppers who want a pretty tray to serve kunafa Not for: Baking or heavy, large platters
| Color | Copper |
|---|---|
| Material | Aluminum |
| Product Dimensions | 11"L x 11"W x 1"H |
| Shape | Round |
| Tray Type | Decorative Tray, Serving Tray |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Food, Drinks, Toiletries, Cosmetic, Jewelry |
| Special Feature | Raised Edge |
| Maximum Weight Recommendation | 1.1 pounds |
| Style Name | Modern |
| Pattern | Hammered |
3. Godinger Burnt Copper Platter: Most Reviewed, Easy Display
Verdict: A 10-inch round burnt-copper-finish platter with the highest review count of the group and a 4.7 rating. Pretty and affordable, but not real copper.
Godinger’s platter has the biggest vote of confidence in this roundup: a 4.7 rating from 458 reviews. It is a 10-inch round platter with a burnt copper finish and a rustic, handcrafted look. Godinger has been in giftware since 1973, so it is a familiar name.
As a serving piece, it is simple and low fuss. The listing mentions fruit, salad, snacks, nuts and candy, and it also works as a centerpiece. A small round kunafa portion or a few sweets would look good on it.
At 10 inches and about an inch high, it is on the compact side, so do not expect to serve a full tray of kunafa. The listing gives few care or heat details, so treat it as a serving and display piece rather than something for the stove or oven.
The bigger caution is the material. The listing says copper, but several owners point out it is not real copper. If that matters, look at the Sertodo platters instead. If you only want the look at a low price, this is a smart buy.
What Owners Say
Owners love the metallic copper appearance and say it works well as a centerpiece. They also praise durability, function and value for money. The recurring complaint is material: several note it is not real copper.
What we like
- Highest review count and a 4.7 rating
- Attractive metallic copper look
- Owners praise durability and value
- Works as a centerpiece or serving platter
- Established giftware brand
What could be better
- Several owners say it is not real copper
- Compact 10-inch size
- Few care and heat instructions listed
- Not a baking pan
Best for: Shoppers who want a pretty copper-look platter at a low cost Not for: Buyers who want solid copper or a baking tray
| Material | Copper |
|---|---|
| Color | Copper |
| Special Feature | Handcrafted |
| Style | Rustic |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Fruit |
| Number of Pieces | 1 |
| Number of Packs | 1 |
| Other Special Features of the Product | Handcrafted |
| Style Name | Rustic |
| Shape | Round |
4. Alisveristime Ottoman Tray: Turkish Style for Serving
Verdict: A 13.6-inch decorative metal tray with Ottoman motifs. It is a charming way to bring kunafa and tea to the table, though it is made for serving.
This tray leans into tradition. It has intricate Turkish motifs and an Ottoman look, and it suits a table where kunafa is served with coffee or tea. At 13.6 inches across and under an inch high, it is roomy enough for a pot, glasses and a few small plates.
It is described as durable and lightweight, which makes carrying it to the table easy. The listing recommends hand washing in warm water and drying with a towel to keep the finish shiny, so it needs a little care, though nothing complicated.
The listing says the material is metal and does not give more detail, so we cannot say whether it is solid or plated. It is also sold as a coffee and tea tray, not for cooking. Buy it for presentation, not baking.
The 4.4 rating across 273 reviews is respectable for a budget tray. Note the pattern is floral and ornate, which some will love and others will find busy. If you want a decorative tray with heritage appeal, it is good value.
What Owners Say
Detailed written feedback is limited, so the 4.4-star average across 273 ratings is the main guide. That volume suggests most owners are satisfied, though there is not enough text to name recurring complaints.
What we like
- Roomy 13.6-inch serving surface
- Traditional Turkish Ottoman motifs
- Lightweight and easy to carry
- Solid 4.4 rating from 273 reviews
- Budget-friendly price tier
What could be better
- Material is only listed as metal
- Hand wash and towel dry required
- Ornate pattern will not suit minimal decor
- Not intended for cooking
Best for: Hosts who want a traditional look for kunafa and tea Not for: Baking or minimalist table settings
| Color | Copper |
|---|---|
| Material | Metal |
| Product Dimensions | 13.78"L x 13.78"W x 0.78"H |
| Shape | Round |
| Tray Type | Serving Tray |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Coffee, Tea |
| Item Type Name | Turkish Ottoman Serving Tray |
| Special Feature | Durable,Lightweight |
| Style Name | Turkish Ottoman Serving Tray |
| Pattern | Floral |
5. Bonito Home 2-Pack: Two Sizes for Hosting
Verdict: A pair of stainless steel round trays in 13 and 15 inches with a hammered, copper-toned finish. Useful for gatherings, but feedback is still thin.
Bonito Home gives you two sizes in one purchase: a 15-inch and a 13-inch round tray. That is handy for a gathering, where one can hold kunafa and the other can hold fruit or cookies. The set is in the under-$50 class, so each tray is inexpensive.
The material is stainless steel in a hammered, copper-toned finish. The listing describes it as scratch- and stain-resistant and shatterproof, and the trays are stackable, which helps with storage. Care is simple: hand wash and dry only.
The finish is described as rose gold and copper toned, so expect a slightly pinker tone than traditional copper. It is a decorative serving set rather than a baking pan, so keep it for the table.
With a 4.4 rating from just 23 reviews, it has the smallest track record among the budget picks. That does not mean it is bad, but it does mean less proof. For hosts who want matching trays at a fair cost, it is a sensible choice.
What Owners Say
There is little written owner feedback so far, and the 4.4 average rests on only 23 ratings. The listing highlights easy cleaning and a responsive support team, but owner patterns are not yet clear.
What we like
- Two trays in 13 and 15 inch sizes
- Stainless steel, scratch- and stain-resistant per listing
- Stackable for easy storage
- Good for gifting and hosting
What could be better
- Only 23 ratings so far
- Rose gold tone rather than classic copper
- Hand wash and dry only
- Not made for baking
Best for: Hosts who want matching serving trays at a fair cost Not for: Cooks who need a stovetop kunafa pan
| Color | Copper |
|---|---|
| Material | Stainless Steel |
| Product Dimensions | 15"L x 15"W x 1"H |
| Shape | Round |
| Tray Type | Serving Tray |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Drinks, Food |
| Special Feature | Shatterproof, Stackable |
| Style Name | Classy |
| Pattern | Solid |
| Occasion | Engagement, Holiday, christmas |
6. Sertodo Thessaly Oval Platter: Pure Copper Premium
Verdict: A hand-hammered pure copper oval platter that is built to be an heirloom. It is the real thing, but it costs far more than the other picks.
This is the only oval option and one of just two solid copper pieces in the group. Sertodo Copper says it uses 100% recycled pure copper and describes heavy-gauge hammered construction. At 16 by 11 inches, it is a generous size for presenting kunafa slices or a mixed dessert spread.
The 4.7 rating comes from 37 reviews, so the sample is small but positive. The listing promotes it for presentation and wall decoration, and the hammered finish gives a warm, real-copper glow that plated trays cannot quite match.
The cost is the obvious obstacle. It is in the premium tier, several times the price of the budget trays. For a beginner who just wants to serve kunafa, that is hard to justify. The listing does not say whether it is meant for stove or oven use, so do not assume it is a baking pan.
Choose it if you want a lasting centerpiece or a gift. If you are watching every dollar, the cheaper trays above deliver most of the look.
What Owners Say
Written feedback is sparse, so the 4.7 rating over 37 reviews is the main signal. It points to satisfied buyers, though the sample is small. The listing itself leans on quality and longevity, not specific owner stories.
What we like
- Solid, recycled pure copper per the listing
- Generous 16 x 11 inch oval
- Strong 4.7 rating
- Hammered finish with a real-copper glow
- Looks like an heirloom piece
What could be better
- Premium price tier
- Only 37 ratings
- Stove or oven suitability not stated
- Real copper tarnishes and needs polishing over time
Best for: Buyers who want a lasting, real copper centerpiece Not for: Budget shoppers or first-time bakers
| Material | Copper |
|---|---|
| Color | Copper |
| Special Feature | Hammered |
| Style | Oval |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Appetizer, Cheese, Fruit, Salad, Meals, Steak, Chicken, Nachos |
| Number of Pieces | 10 |
| Number of Packs | 1 |
| Other Special Features of the Product | Hammered |
| Style Name | Oval |
| Shape | Oval |
7. Sertodo Thessaly Rectangle Platter: Pure Copper Alternative
Verdict: The rectangular twin of the oval Sertodo platter, with the same pure hammered copper and the same premium price. Pick the shape that suits your table.
This platter shares the oval’s materials and ratings: hand-hammered pure copper from recycled sources, a 4.7 average from 37 reviews and a 16 by 11 inch footprint. The difference is the shape. A rectangle fits a long buffet or a rectangular kunafa cut into neat squares.
The listing highlights durability, sustainability and handcrafting. It suggests appetizers, cheese, fruit, salad and charcuterie, so serving is the clear focus. Nothing indicates it is a baking tray.
As with the oval, you pay a premium for solid copper. That is a heavy spend compared with trays that look similar but cost much less. The listing also gives a confusing shape field, listing oval, rectangular, round and square, so double-check you are ordering the rectangle.
It ranks just below the oval because the two are otherwise equal, and the oval has a slightly more flexible look. If you already know you want a rectangular spread, this is a fine alternative. Otherwise, save money with a plated tray and enjoy the same kunafa.
What Owners Say
There is little written owner feedback, so the 4.7 average across 37 ratings is the main guide. Buyers appear satisfied, but there are not enough comments to identify clear complaints or recurring praise.
What we like
- Solid recycled copper per the listing
- Rectangle shape suits cut kunafa squares
- High 4.7 rating
- Handcrafted and built to last
- Large 16 x 11 inch surface
What could be better
- Premium price tier
- Small review sample of 37
- Not marketed for baking
- Listing shape details are confusing
- Real copper needs polishing
Best for: Buffet hosts who want a lasting rectangular copper platter Not for: Tight budgets and stovetop baking
| Material | Copper |
|---|---|
| Color | Copper |
| Special Feature | Durability, Sustainable, Handcrafted, Eco-Friendly |
| Style | Rectangle |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Appetizer, Cheese, Fruit, Salad, Charcuterie, Nachos |
| Number of Pieces | 10 |
| Item Type Name | platter |
| Reusability | Reusable |
| Number of Packs | 1 |
| Style Name | Rectangle |
8. Achla Designs Square Tray 10 Inch: Small and Stylish
Verdict: A 10-inch square stainless steel tray with a copper-plated finish and a 4.6 rating. It is attractive and light, but small, and the listing is aimed more at plants and decor.
The Achla square tray has a respectable 4.6 rating from 51 reviews. It is a 10-inch square with a rolled edge, about one inch high and about a pound in weight. The handmade, copper-plated stainless steel develops a natural patina over time.
The listing says it works for serving food and drinks, as a plant tray or for display. That breadth is a plus for flexibility, but this is not a kunafa baking pan. At 10 inches it also fits only a small portion of dessert.
Because each tray is handmade, the maker notes dimensions may vary slightly. The patina is a selling point for a rustic look, though it may bother anyone who wants a constant shine.
The listing shows no current price or stock status, which makes budgeting difficult. Check what it costs before you commit. It ranks near the bottom because the size is limited and the listing has little guidance for cooking or care. It remains a decent decorative choice.
What Owners Say
Written feedback is limited, so the 4.6 average over 51 ratings is the main clue. It suggests buyers are generally happy with its looks, though there is not enough text to flag specific complaints.
What we like
- 4.6 rating from 51 reviews
- Light at about a pound
- Rolled edge and clean square shape
- Patina gives a rustic look
- Flexible for decor, plants or serving
What could be better
- Small 10-inch size
- Price and stock not clearly shown
- Dimensions vary slightly because it is handmade
- Not made for baking
Best for: Small tables and decorative displays Not for: Large servings or stovetop baking
| Color | Copper |
|---|---|
| Material | Stainless Steel |
| Product Dimensions | 10.5"L x 10.5"W x 1"H |
| Shape | Square |
| Tray Type | Serving Tray/Plant Tray |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Food |
| Included Components | Tray |
| Item Type Name | Square Copper TRay |
| Special Feature | Lightweight |
| Style Name | Classic |
9. Achla Designs Round Tray 12 Inch: Mixed Quality Reports
Verdict: A 12-inch round copper-plated stainless steel tray that doubles as a plant saucer. Owners find it pretty, but quality reports are mixed and some warn against food use.
This 12-inch round tray is attractive and light, at about one inch high and about a pound. It is made from copper-plated stainless steel with a rolled edge and develops a patina with age. The price is in the budget class.
The catch is how it is categorized. It is listed under garden plant saucers, and the feature list leans on plant trays. Some owners warn against using it for food, which is a red flag for a kunafa buyer. The listing itself does say it can serve food, so the guidance is conflicting.
Quality is also a mixed bag. Some owners praise its beauty and sturdiness, while others find it low quality. A 4.3 rating from 114 reviews fits that picture: good, but not dependable.
Because each tray is handmade, sizes can vary a bit. If you want a copper tray for display, a coffee table or a plant, it is fine. For kunafa, buy one of the alternatives above with clearer food guidance.
What Owners Say
Owners find it beautiful and sturdy, but quality reports are mixed, with some calling it low quality. A recurring caution is that several owners say not to use it for food, despite the listing’s serving suggestions.
What we like
- Attractive copper-plated look
- Light at about a pound
- Owners call it beautiful and sturdy
- Budget price tier
What could be better
- Mixed quality reports
- Some owners warn against using it for food
- Listed as a plant saucer
- Handmade, so sizes may vary
Best for: Decor on a coffee table or under plants Not for: Serving or baking kunafa
| Color | Copper |
|---|---|
| Material | Stainless Steel |
| Product Dimensions | 12.5"L x 12.5"W x 1"H |
| Shape | Round |
| Tray Type | Round |
| Recommended Uses For Product | Coffee, Food, Tea |
| Included Components | Tray |
| Item Type Name | Round Copper Tray |
| Special Feature | Lightweight |
| Style Name | Traditional |
How They Compare
The nine trays fall into three groups. The DLK set is the only baking-ready option. MyGift, Godinger, Alisveristime, Bonito and both Achla trays are budget-class serving or decor pieces. The two Sertodo platters are the only solid copper and sit in the premium tier.
For first-time kunafa makers, pairing the DLK pan with a pretty serving tray such as the MyGift gives you function and looks while staying under a premium spend. Owner ratings were highest for Godinger and the Sertodo platters, but the latter rest on far fewer reviews.
What to Look for in Copper Kunafa Tray
Intended use
Check whether the tray is for baking or only for serving and decor.
Look for: Stove-safe wording, such as gas stove safe, for baking kunafa
Avoid: Plant saucers or decor trays with warnings about food use
Material
Copper, copper-plated and coated metals behave differently and cost differently.
Look for: A clearly stated material and finish
Avoid: Listings that say copper without saying solid or plated
Size and depth
Kunafa needs enough inner diameter for the recipe and a shallow edge.
Look for: An inner diameter around 11 to 12 inches and a height near one inch
Avoid: Trays under 10 inches if you plan to serve several people
Care and durability
Thin metal and fine finishes need careful washing.
Look for: Clear hand-wash guidance and a durable finish
Avoid: Abrasive scrubbers and bleach
Price per tray
Sets can lower the cost per tray, while premium copper rarely improves a beginner's results.
Look for: Sets or budget-tier trays with strong review counts
Avoid: Paying premium prices for a first attempt
Copper Kunafa Tray Buying Guide
How to Choose the Best Copper Kunafa Tray
Start with what you will do with it. If you plan to bake kunafa on a stovetop, you need a tray sold for that job. Look for words such as gas stove safe, and check the thickness, because thin metal heats quickly and evenly for small batches. If you only plan to serve kunafa, any attractive round or square tray will do.
Copper, Copper-Plated or Copper-Look
Pure copper looks the best and lasts for years, but it costs the most and tarnishes, so it needs polishing. Copper-plated aluminum or stainless steel gives a similar glow for much less. Some trays just have a copper-colored coating, and a few owners note this on cheaper listings. Read the material line before you buy.
Size, Edge and Weight
For most home kunafa recipes, an inner diameter near 11 to 12 inches and a shallow edge are comfortable. Remember that outer diameter is larger than the usable inside. Light trays are easy to flip and carry, while heavier ones hold heat longer. A raised edge helps when you move syrup-soaked pastry.
Care and Budget Tips for Beginners
Most trays here want hand washing, soft sponges and prompt drying. Avoid wire brushes and bleach, which can scratch or stain the finish. On budget, a set can be a smart choice because you get a second tray for batches or serving. Spend on one baking pan first, then add a nicer serving tray later if you want one.
How We Picked
We compared each tray’s listed material, dimensions, weight, stove suitability, care instructions and price tier. We then weighed Amazon owner rating patterns, giving more weight to larger review counts and to repeated praise or complaints.
Because this audience is budget-minded and often new to kunafa, we favored ease of use, clear intended use and value over prestige materials. We did not run lab tests; rankings reflect spec analysis and owner feedback.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I bake kunafa in a decorative copper tray?
Usually not. Most trays here are sold for serving or decor, and the listings do not mention stove or oven use. Only the DLK set is described as gas stove safe. Check the product wording for heat guidance before cooking, and keep decorative trays for presenting the finished dessert.
Is copper-plated as good as pure copper for kunafa?
For serving, plated trays look similar and cost far less. Pure copper is heavier, lasts longer and develops a real patina, but it needs polishing and sits in the premium tier. For a beginner, the extra spend seldom improves the dessert. Choose pure copper mainly for gifting or an heirloom look.
What size tray do I need for kunafa?
For a family-sized dessert, an inner diameter around 11 to 12 inches is a common fit. The DLK pan lists an 11.75-inch inner diameter. Smaller 10-inch trays suit individual portions or display. Always compare the inner measurement, not just the outer diameter, against your recipe.
How do I clean a copper-look tray?
Most listings advise hand washing with warm, soapy water and drying with a towel straight away. Skip wire brushes and bleach, which can damage finishes. Dishwashers are not recommended for the DLK or Bonito sets. Gentle care keeps plated surfaces shiny and slows patina or tarnish.
Which tray is the best value for a beginner?
The DLK set is the best value if you want to bake, because you get two stove-ready trays in an under-$50 class bundle. If you only need to serve, MyGift and Godinger offer strong ratings at budget prices. Premium Sertodo platters look lovely but are difficult to justify for a first purchase.
Final Thoughts
The best copper kunafa tray for most beginners is a two-step plan: a stove-ready pan for baking and an affordable copper-look tray for serving. Buy for how you will use it, and save premium copper for later.
- Choose the DLK set if you want to bake kunafa at home
- Pick MyGift or Godinger for budget-friendly serving
- Skip the Achla round tray if you plan to serve food
If you are watching your budget, start with the DLK set for baking and add the MyGift tray for presenting. That pairing keeps costs low and the process simple. Splurge on Sertodo only when you want a keepsake. We hope this guide from muslimrestaurant.com helps you choose with confidence.
How this guide was made
No product was bought or physically tested for it. Editorial responsibility: Muslimrestaurant Editorial. Read the full method.


















1 comment